Here’s how it reaches your plan. When an employee receives care from an out-of-network provider they didn’t choose, like an ER physician at an in-network hospital, the No Surprises Act protects them from a surprise bill. Your plan pays the provider instead. If the provider wants more, they can take it to independent dispute resolution (IDR): each side submits a price, and an arbitrator picks one, with no middle ground.1 Whatever the arbitrator chooses, your plan pays. Those dollars flow into your renewal and, eventually, into your employees’ premiums, out-of-pocket costs, and even raises.
Arbitration was meant to be rare. Regulators expected about 22,000 disputes a year; in 2025, providers filed 2.6 million.1 Georgetown researchers estimate IDR has cost $22.4 billion since 2022, including $16.6 billion in 2025 alone.1
Providers won about 85% of disputes, with a median award of 445% of the qualifying payment amount (QPA), or what is roughly the median in-network rate.1 Plans offered at or above the QPA in about 90% of disputes, yet still won only 15% of the time2.
The high cost and high volume of arbitration is noticed by regulators and reform is on the way, though relief likely won’t arrive before calendar year 2028, or by the time you’ve already completed your next two renewals.
Until then, the risk sits squarely with you. Self-funded plans don’t hand IDR costs to an insurer; you absorb them in claims, and they are compounding. Disputes in the first half of 2026 ran 50% ahead of the same period in 2025.1 Providers can also use IDR wins as leverage, staying out of network or pressing for higher in-network rates and each award shapes expectations for future payments. 1,4
That makes the coming year yours to shape. Ask your TPA how many disputes are hitting your plan, who is filing them, and what you’re paying. Confirm that ineligible disputes are being challenged; payers contested eligibility in 41% of 2025 disputes.1 Then build IDR trends into your renewal assumptions.
You don’t have to navigate it alone. Bolton is helping employers measure their IDR exposure, hold vendors accountable, and bring the employer perspective to reform conversations.
Liz Gardner | lgardner@boltonusa.com
Sources
- Jack Hoadley and Kennah Watts, “Spending On IDR Process Pushes No Surprises Act Costs To More Than $22.4 Billion Over Just Four Years,” Health Affairs Forefront, August 26, 2026. https://www.healthaffairs.org/content/forefront/spending-idr-process-pushes-no-surprises-act-costs-more-than-22-4-billion-over-just
- Kennah Watts and Jack Hoadley, “Unpacking the Offers: What Three Years of Data Do and Don’t Reveal About Insurer Behavior in IDR,” Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms, November 11, 2026. https://chir.georgetown.edu/unpacking-the-offers-what-three-years-of-data-do-and-dont-reveal-about-insurer-behavior-in-idr/
- Steve Randall, “No Surprises Act reform could cut employer benefits costs,” Insurance Business, October 28, 2026. https://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/us/news/benefits/no-surprises-act-reform-could-cut-employer-benefits-costs-595175.aspx
- Christine Cooper, “Managing IDR Risk: What Employers And Plan Sponsors Can Do Now,” Forbes, October 20, 2026. https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinesscouncil/2026/10/20/managing-idr-risk-what-employers-and-plan-sponsors-can-do-now/